Dear Bishops, we greet you in the name of Christ and on behalf of MARCHA (Methodists Associated Representing the Cause of Hispanic/Latinx Americans). We write to you with a troubled heart and concern about the long and over-extended suspension of Bishop Minerva Carcaño and its effects on the Hispanic/Latinx ministry and the witness of our entire Church.
MARCHA continues to be deeply grieved that one of the most influential voices in our community and the entire United Methodist connection is and continues to be silenced. Bishop Carcaño’s courageous advocacy on behalf of immigrants and her deep commitment to fighting injustices in our society has won the admiration and respect of many people in our Church, leaders in other denominations, and civic groups. MARCHA is especially concerned that in the last meeting of the Council of Bishops, the Immigration Task Force, which was effectively led by Bishop Carcaño in the past, did not offer a report. At this moment, when the refugee and immigration crisis continues to increase due to war and other conflicts, her leadership is sorely missed.
We question the fact that the Western Jurisdiction College of Bishops and Committee on Episcopacy placed Bishop Carcaño in suspension, even before the process of investigation began to ascertain the veracity of the allegations. We know that many bishops are subject to complaints. Yet, no other Jurisdictional College in the history of the United Methodist Church has placed a bishop in suspension before the proper committee had investigated the complaint. This suspension has now been extended, without regard to the adverse effects. The rumors that are circulating in our Church regarding this matter create feelings of resentment and distrust in the judicial processes of our Church among the Hispanic/Latinx United Methodists and others. At this moment in our Church, trust is crucial.
MARCHA believes it is necessary to question the United Methodist Church, a predominantly white institution, when it has different standards for BIPOC (Black, Indigenous, People of Color) leaders, as opposed to white leaders, particularly in complaint processes. The uncertainty of the Council of Bishops’ stated commitment to dismantling racism is disheartening when it is not experienced in our Hispanic/Latinx community. The Western Jurisdiction College’s decision to depart from precedent with regard to the practice of due process raises a critical question in our minds: Why is a Hispanic/Latina woman Bishop being treated differently?
Therefore, given the length of the suspension imposed, the possible lack of impartiality, the unprecedented beginning of the complaint process, and the proliferation of rumors circulation in the Western Jurisdiction, MARCHA respectfully requests that the Council of Bishops will remove the complaints against Bishop Carcaño from the College and assume responsibility for processing them.
“The Council of Bishops may, at any time in the process, after a complaint is filed, including after a just resolution, remove the complaint from the College of Bishops to the Council of Bishops with a two-thirds vote by the Council.” (Par. 413.d.iv, 2016 Book of Discipline).
The Council of Bishops has the power to intervene and take a restorative role in addressing the harm done to the entire connection. We pray the Council of Bishops will witness its commitment to providing an equitable and fair process.
MARCHA calls our Church to continue surrounding in prayer all parties involved. MARCHA intends to continue closely monitoring the progress of this process as we walk alongside justice.
Rev. Lyssette Perez, President
Rev. Nora Colmenares, Vice President
Rev. Héctor A. Burgos, Communications
Rev. Raquel Feagins, Secretary
Rev. Joel Hortiales, Strategy
Pastor Imelda Román de Gómez, Administration
Dr. Ilia Vázquez-Gascot, Education
Raúl Alegría – Treasurer
Andrés de Arco – Young Adult
Sign the Letter and Petition to the Council of Bishops
Also signed by,
Doug Ruffle, Greater New Jersey Annual Conference
Jeannette Zajac Greater NJ
Rev Dr Enna Antunez Iowa Annual Conference
Gricelda G Careaga. Río Texas Conference
Sandra Sypherd Great Plains Conference
Rev. Lyssette Perez, MARCHA, GNJ Annual Conference
Raul Alegría – Tennessee- Western Kentucky
Michael G Rivas, Florida conference
Rev. Paula Cripps-Vallejo, Northern Illinois Conference
Rev. José Esteban Rivera-Bocanegra Greater NewJersey Annual Conference
Pastor Luis Daniel Román-Hernández / Iglesia Metodista de Puerto Rico
Nilka Marrero Garcia Puerto Rico Conference
Diana Jani Darak-Druck New York Annual Conference
MARY SILVA- RIO TEXAS CONFERENCE
Maritza Gonzalez, Greater New Jersey
Mcwilliam Colon Greater New Jersey Annual conference
Imelda Roman Wisconsin Conference
Lori Valentine de Segovia, Virginia Annual Conference
Lilian Cotto EPAC
Rev. Liliana Padilla Rio Texas Conference
Paloma Rodriguez-Rivera, Puerto Rico Conference
Michael Bergman, Mountain Sky Conference
Rev. David K. Farley, California Pacific Conference
David Jaimes, CALPAC
Luis Daniel Roman-Hernandez / Iglesia Metodista de Puerto Rico
Rev. Dr. Sammy Arroyo
Rev. Aida Luz Beltrán-Gaetán
Rev. Alejandro Alfaro-Santiz Iowa Annual Conference
George Lockwood Pacific Northwood
James Duane Perdue, Iowa Onference
Iris Chavez Rio Texas Annual Conference
Philip Wingeier-Rayo, Baltimore-Washington
Ediberto López-Rodríguez NYAC
Ramon Bello.Great Plains.
Fernando J Vazquez
Edith Zewadski-Bricker – Florida Conference
Sonya Luna, Michigan Conference
Juan Quintanilla NGC
Alma L Matos, GNJ
Rev. Dr Ivelisse Quiñones SG
Eileen Rivera Greater New Jersey Conference
Valerie L Mendoza
Alma Pérez- TWK
Jose Luis Palos Rio Texas Conference
Sabrina Martinez
Rev. Dr. Jose A Carrión Aquino. FLUMC
Manuel chavez jr Rio Grande
Rev. Carmen M. Gaud Desert Southwest
Rev. Dr. Diana L. Hynson, Baltimore–Washington Annual Conference
Eliezer Valentín-Castañón, Baltimore Washington Conference
Normary Rodriguez, GNJUMC
Juan Carlos Ruiz / Greater New Jersey
Rev. Cricket Denton GNJ
Rev dr Miguel Balderas. Baltimore Washington conference
Dr. C. Anthony Hunt, Baltimore-Washington Conference
Carole Davenport, Northern Illinois Conference
Eunice Garcia Rio Texas Conference
Rafael Moreno Rivas, Iglesia Metodista de Puerto Rico
Julia Puac-Romero, North Texas
Ramon Ramirez-Rio Texas Conference
Julia Puac-Romero, North Texas
Rev. Matthew Mariani, Northern Illinois Annual Conference
Rev. Sara Giron-Ortiz, New York Annual
Rev. Dr. Juan. G. Feliciano-Valera, Puerto Rico
Nilda Ferrari/ VA AC
Rev. Charles Kyle
Rev. Isidro Piña Rio Texas Conference
Héctor Soto Vélez Puerto Rico
Rev. Fabiola Grandon-Mayer Northern Illinois Conference
Miriam Peralta, Michigan
Rev. Myriam Cortes- Tennessee Western Kentucky
Rev. Dr. Leo Yates Baltimore-Washington Conference
Miros Villarreal. Rio Texas Conference
Rev. Teresa Pena Rio Texas Conference
Rvdo. Julio Vargas, PR Annual Conference and UMC endorsed to the Army Chaplaincy
Efrain Cotto, Jr., Eastern Penn. Conference
Rev. Dr. Richard Romero, Greater New Jersey
Rvda.Diaconisa Maria Teresa Santiago IMPR
Migdiel E. Perez, Tennessee/ Western Kentucky
Ian Straker New York Annual Conference
Josefina Pérez / CalPac Conference
Kim Cape Cal-Nevada
Bilha Ramírez Alegría/TN/Western KY
Joan Clark, Oregon-Idaho annual conference
J. Ann Craig, New York
Dr. Neva Fuentes, Rio Texas Conference
Rev. Thelma Herrera Flores-Rio Texas
Rev. Yeika A. Huertas Román IM de Puerto Rico sirviendo en Greater New Jersey Conference
Rev Sonia E Brum, SC
Daisy Tavarez NYAC
Rev. Isabel Gomez ret. Rio Texas conference
Susan L ODell, PhD Oregon-Idaho Conference
Ann Needham Bower, Oklahoma
Cesar García Rodríguez, Michigan
Rev. Karina Feliz, NYAC
Leta Evelyn Gullatt. Rio Texas
Eric A. Hernandez Lopez, Puerto Rico
Luis F Reyes, Northern Illinois
Ellen Kirby, Western North Carolina Conference
Karen Eaker North Texas Conference
Eddie Gouge, Baltimore-Washington Conference
Shirley Durr, Minnesota Annual Conference
Rev. Dr. Felicisimo Cao California-Nevada Conference
Rev. Sherrie Lowly, Northern Illinois
Kylie Nelson, Oregon-Idaho Conference
Hannah Phillips Mollenkamp, North Texas Conference
Joyce Sohl Arkansas
Rev. Lane Cotton Winn, Louisiana
Rev. Pam Cahoon, Fl Conference
Rev. Brian Lee Daugherty- West Virginia Annual Conference
Obed J. Pérez- Greater New Jersey
Stephen Bryant. Rio Texas Conference
Bishop Emeritus Rev. Dr. Ramon Hernandez
Rev Dr. Ramón Hernandez-Lopez, Bishop Emeritus. Iglesia Metodista de PR
Rev. Scott Marsh, Michigan Annual Conference
Esmeralda Mendoza south rio texas
Sam Mendoza, south rio texas
Pastor Daniel Levine NYAC
Eradio Valverde, Rio Texas
Rev. Dr. David T. Grout, Kentucky Annual Conf
Rev. Francisco Arroyo Northern Illinois Annual Conference
Rev. Ivelisse Garay Bishop-GNJUMC
Rev Jorge Rodriguez Vasquez President MARCHA WEST
Mark R. Sills, WNCC
Felix Tshibang
Betty J. Letzig, Western North Carolina
Kim A DonnellySummers Desert Southwest
Rev. Martha E. Swords-Horrell. Upper New York Conference
Peter K Lau, California-Nevada Conference
Diana Carcaño- Rio Texas Conference
Arabella Chavez, Rio Texas
Western North Carolina
Andrea Paret, Great Plains Conference
Rev. John D. Current, California- Nevada Annual Conference
- Betsy Careaga, Río Texas conference
Bryan Wilson, Northern Illinois Annual Conference
Eunice Vega-Perez GNJ
Rev. Dr. Drew A. Dyson, Greater NJ
Scott Gallagher WPA
Rev. Tom Lank, Greater New Jersey
Rev. Virginia Samuel Cetuk
Rev. Rosario L. Quinones, GNJ
Pastora Elizabeth González GNJ
María Milagros Rivera- BW Conference
Rev. Rolando Santiago- Fuentes – GNJAC
Juarez Gonçalves New England Conference
Dori Fotsch, Cal Pac
Rev Manuel Sardinas, GNJ
Lourdes L. Matos, Greater NJ Annual Conference
Rosa Yáñez-Islas
Allie Lakey, Desert Southwest
Gredda Marrero, Florida Conference
- Theresa McConnell, Louisiana
Rev. Joseph McCarthy, GNJAC
Rachel McConnell-Switzer, Louisiana Annual Conference
Rev. Linda Butler, Iowa Annual Conference
Deen Thompson TNWKY Conference
Deaconess Allison Francesco, Susquehanna Annual Conference
Rev. Dr. Bradford Motta. Greater New Jersey.
Sehee Han, California Pacific Conference
Laurie Kaufman de la Garza. Michigan Conference
Rev. Shawn Lelion Greater NJ
Edward G Martin, Greater New Jersey
Cyndi Stouffer – Greater NJ
Charles T. McNeil, Greater NJ
Rev. George Morris, Greater New Jersey, Retired
Rev. Heather Valosin, GNJ
Paul Smith, New York Annual Conference
Rev. Victoria Wood Parrish – New England Annual Conference
Rev Ed Carll. GNJ
Rev. Dr. Jeffrey D. Sterling, Western PA Conference
Rev. Perrin Crouch, Missouri Annual Conference
Rev. Kate Mackereth Fulton, Baltimore-Washington Conference
Patricia Bellingrath Holston Conference
Doug Cunningham, New York Annual Conference
Theresa McConnell
Nancy Reding CA/NV Conference
Diane Dyson greater NJ Conference
Rev. M Jade Kaiser (Barclay) – Northern Illinois Conference
Javier F Careaga-Rio Texas Conference
Joseph Tognetti Rio Texas
Rev. Dawn Maffetone, Greater New jersey Annual Conference
Rev. Nydia Irizarry- Jara / Rio Texas Conference
Rev Pat Watkins Virginia AC
Rev. Christina C. Zito Greater New Jersey AC
Rev. Gary Frieze, Greater NJ
Debra A. De Vos, Greater New Jersey
Rev. Marissa van der Valk Greater New Jersey Annual Conference
Sharon Gallagher Wpa
Rev Diane Pacione GNJ
Rev. Jennifer Lovallo, GNJ
Rev Amanda Hemenetz, Greater New Jersey
Rev. Jessica Brendler Naulty, GNJ
Jim Bielefeldt Greater NJ Conference
Isaac Simmons: Illinois Great Rivers Conference